Sample — generated from a fictional minute book
Minute book review
FileFlow Solutions Inc.
Incorp #: BC1234567Incorp date: 2023-10-17Annual ref: Not found in minute bookReviewed: 2026-04-28
Executive summary
FileFlow Solutions Inc. is a BC sole-director, sole-shareholder private company incorporated October 17, 2023, with Jane Chen as sole director, sole officer, and sole holder of 100 Class A Common shares. The minute book contains the constating documents, organizational resolutions, registers, 2024 annual resolutions, and a December 2025 dividend declaration. Several items warrant attention: the Transparency Register required under Part 4.1 of the BCA does not appear in the index or contents; share certificate A-001 appears unsigned (signature line empty under President signature block); and 2025 annual resolutions (due by approximately mid-January 2026 based on the October 17 anniversary) are not present, though the deadline may not yet have passed depending on the actual annual reference date. Overall the book is well-organized for an early-stage sole-shareholder company but requires the noted updates before sign-off.
Issues
2 action required · 5 recommended · 2 FYI
Action required
Transparency Register not present in minute book
Compliance · ISS-001Finding
The index (Tab list, Tabs 1–14) does not include a Transparency Register, and no such register appears anywhere in the 41-page minute book. The Company was incorporated on October 17, 2023, well after the October 1, 2020 in-force date for Part 4.1 of the BCA.
Why it matters
Part 4.1 of the BCA requires every private BC company to maintain a Transparency Register of significant individuals and to update it at least annually and upon becoming aware of changes. Absence of this register is a statutory non-compliance issue.
Recommended action
Prepare and add a Transparency Register identifying Jane Chen as the significant individual (sole shareholder holding 100% of voting shares), including the prescribed information under s. 119.11. Confirm with the client whether a Transparency Register has been maintained separately and, if so, place a copy in the minute book.
Share Certificate A-001 appears unsigned
Compliance · ISS-002Finding
Share Certificate No. A-001 at Tab 9 (pages 28–29) shows the signature line above 'Jane Chen, President' on page 29 but the OCR/text indicates only the printed name and title — no signature notation appears. Article 2.2 requires share certificates to be signed as required by the BCA.
Why it matters
Under s. 57 of the BCA, share certificates must be signed by the directors or officers as the Articles require. An unsigned certificate may not validly evidence the shareholder's interest and is inconsistent with the directors' organizational resolution at Tab 5 directing issuance of a share certificate.
Recommended action
Confirm whether the original certificate in the physical minute book is signed. If not, have Jane Chen sign Certificate A-001 as President. If signed in original but not visible in scan, note this on the reviewer's working copy.
Recommended
Confirm 2025 annual resolutions status and annual reference date
Compliance · ISS-003Finding
The minute book contains annual resolutions for 2024 (Tab 13, dated October 17, 2024) but no 2025 annual resolutions. The Company was incorporated October 17, 2023, so the second anniversary fell on October 17, 2025.
Why it matters
Under s. 182 of the BCA, an AGM (or consent resolution in lieu) must be held within 15 months of the previous annual reference date. Depending on the actual annual reference date, the 2025 annual resolutions may already be due or may be imminent. The audit waiver granted at Tab 13 covered only the year ending October 31, 2025.
Recommended action
Confirm the Company's annual reference date with BC Corporate Online. Prepare 2025 annual consent resolutions covering: receipt of FY October 31, 2025 financial statements, re-election of director, s. 203 audit waiver for FY ending October 31, 2026, and confirmation of acts. Confirm BC annual report has been filed.
Notice of Articles share structure inconsistent with share certificate
Compliance · ISS-004Finding
The Notice of Articles at Tab 1 (page 5) describes the authorized share structure as 'No Maximum number of Class A Common shares' and 'No Maximum number of Class B Common shares' with 'special rights or restrictions attached: No' for both classes. Share Certificate A-001 at Tab 9 describes the shares as 'Class A Common Shares Without Par Value' (voting) and the CSR at Tab 10 distinguishes Class A as voting and Class B as non-voting.
Why it matters
If the Class A and Class B shares have differing voting rights, those differences are special rights or restrictions that must be set out in the Articles and reflected on the Notice of Articles. The Notice of Articles indicating 'No' special rights is inconsistent with treating the classes as voting/non-voting.
Recommended action
Review the Articles (Tab 4) for any special rights or restrictions provisions for Class A and Class B shares — the Articles as reproduced do not appear to set out class-specific rights. Reconcile the Notice of Articles, the Articles, the share certificate, and the CSR. If special rights exist, confirm proper alteration filings; if not, correct the CSR descriptions and confirm both classes rank equally.
Confirm dividend payment and tax treatment documentation
Compliance · ISS-005Finding
The December 15, 2025 dividend declaration at Tab 14 declares a $5,000 cash dividend designated as an 'eligible dividend' under s. 89(1) of the Income Tax Act (Canada), payable on or before December 31, 2025.
Why it matters
An 'eligible dividend' designation requires the payor corporation to have a sufficient General Rate Income Pool (GRIP) balance and to provide the recipient with written notice of the eligible designation at or before the time the dividend is paid. A CCPC with active business income subject to the small business deduction typically pays non-eligible dividends rather than eligible dividends.
Recommended action
Confirm with the Company's accountant that a GRIP balance exists to support the eligible dividend designation. If the dividend is more appropriately a non-eligible (ordinary) dividend, prepare a corrective resolution. Ensure written notice of designation was provided to the shareholder and a T5 slip is being prepared.
Inconsistency between Articles quorum and sole shareholder reality
Hygiene · ISS-006Finding
Article 6.3 (Tab 4, page 14) states the quorum for shareholder meetings is 'two persons present' with a proviso that if the Company has only one shareholder, the quorum is that one shareholder. The Articles also state in Article 5.4 that quorum for directors is one if there is a sole director.
Why it matters
These provisions appear internally consistent and accommodate the sole-shareholder/sole-director structure. No correction needed, but reviewer should be aware that any future addition of a second shareholder will change the quorum requirement.
Recommended action
No action required at this time. Note for file: if additional shareholders are admitted, the two-person quorum will apply going forward.
Share Subscription accepted by subscriber on behalf of Company
Hygiene · ISS-007Finding
The Share Subscription at Tab 8 (page 25) was offered by Jane Chen as subscriber and accepted by Jane Chen as Director on behalf of the Company on October 17, 2023.
Why it matters
While permissible in a sole-director, sole-shareholder context, self-dealing on subscription should be supported by clear directors' resolutions accepting the subscription and authorizing issuance — which is present at Tab 5. No conflict-of-interest declaration appears, but in a sole-director sole-shareholder context this is generally acceptable.
Recommended action
No corrective action needed. Note the structure for future reference if additional shareholders are introduced.
FYI
Banking resolution form not in minute book
Hygiene · ISS-008Finding
Section 6 of the organizational directors' resolutions (Tab 5, page 17) adopts 'the form of banking resolution required by such bank or financial institution,' but no banking resolution form, account opening documentation, or bank designation is included in the minute book.
Why it matters
Banking resolutions are typically maintained outside the minute book at the bank's request, but a copy in the minute book is best practice for completeness.
Recommended action
Request a copy of any executed banking resolution from the client and include it in the minute book for completeness.
No Register of Mortgages or other ancillary registers
Hygiene · ISS-009Finding
The minute book does not include a Register of Mortgages or evidence of LOTA/LOTR filings.
Why it matters
Section 42 of the BCA prescribes records that must be maintained at the records office, including a register of indebtedness for which the company has granted security. If the Company has not granted any security and does not hold any interest in land, these are not required.
Recommended action
Confirm with the client whether the Company has granted any security or holds any interest in land. If yes, add the appropriate registers and LOTR filing confirmations.
Company snapshot
Type
Sole-director company (s. 137 applies). Sole-shareholder company (s. 182 applies). Post-BCA incorporation (no Part 12 transition required). Fiscal year-end October 31. Audit waiver in place to October 31, 2025.
Directors
Jane Chen
Officers
Jane Chen (President), Jane Chen (Secretary), Jane Chen (Treasurer)
Share structure
Authorized: unlimited Class A Common shares without par value; unlimited Class B Common shares without par value. Issued and outstanding: 100 Class A Common shares held by Jane Chen (Certificate A-001, issued October 17, 2023 for $100). No Class B shares issued.
Registered office
Suite 800, 1000 West Georgia Street, Vancouver, BC V6E 2Y3
Records office
Suite 800, 1000 West Georgia Street, Vancouver, BC V6E 2Y3
Minute book completeness
The minute book is well-organized with a clear index covering 14 tabs and contains the core constating documents, organizational resolutions, registers (CSR, Directors, Officers), 2024 annual resolutions, and a December 2025 dividend declaration. The most material gaps are the absence of a Transparency Register (required under Part 4.1 of the BCA since October 1, 2020) and the apparent absence of 2025 annual resolutions. Several share-structure inconsistencies between the Notice of Articles, Articles, and CSR/share certificate should be reconciled.
This report is generated by Reede for review purposes only and is not legal advice. All findings should be verified by a qualified BC corporate lawyer or paralegal before action is taken.
This is a sample report from a fictional company. Sign up to review your own.
Try your own minute book